US Supreme Court To Hear NC Man's Case - myfoxcarolinas.com

US Supreme Court To Hear NC Man's Case

Posted: Updated:
  • Joe BrunoMore>>

  • Bessemer City Kings Mountain Drive-In To Close

    Bessemer City Kings Mountain Drive-In To Close

    Friday, August 29 2014 10:47 PM EDT2014-08-30 02:47:23 GMT
    For 65 years, families have enjoyed the Bessemer City Kings Mountain Drive-In Theatre.At $10 a carload, the drive-in has welcomed thousands. This weekend, the drive-in will roll films for the final time.
    For 65 years, families have enjoyed the Bessemer City Kings Mountain Drive-In Theatre.At $10 a carload, the drive-in has welcomed thousands. This weekend, the drive-in will roll films for the final time.
  • Border Wars: North and South Carolina

    Border Wars: North and South Carolina

    Thursday, August 28 2014 11:38 PM EDT2014-08-29 03:38:04 GMT
    North and South Carolina have a battle over the border going on. Where Gaston County, North Carolina meets York County, South Carolina is up in the air. The Ourfalian family lives just on the edge of that boundary. They have two addresses.
    North and South Carolina have a battle over the border going on. Where Gaston County, North Carolina meets York County, South Carolina is up in the air. The Ourfalian family lives just on the edge of that boundary. They have two addresses.
  • Congressman Pittenger Holds Town Hall Meeting

    Congressman Pittenger Holds Town Hall Meeting

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 11:19 PM EDT2014-08-28 03:19:16 GMT
    Republican Congressman Robert Pittenger held a town hall meeting in Mooresville, Wednesday evening. Dozens of people fired questions at Pittenger, who represents North Carolina's 9th District, and is running for reelection unopposed.
    Republican Congressman Robert Pittenger held a town hall meeting in Mooresville, Wednesday evening. Dozens of people fired questions at Pittenger, who represents North Carolina's 9th District, and is running for reelection unopposed.
What started as a failed bank robbery in September 2008 led to a Belmont woman's death, but in an unusual way.

Larry Whitfield tried to rob Fort Financial Credit Union in Gastonia with an AK-47 but his attempt failed. During Whitfield's escape, he cornered 79-year-old Mary Parnell in her own home.

Parnell died of a heart attack in her computer room. Whitfield was originally sentenced to life in prison, essentially for scaring Parnell to death. But his conviction was tossed by an appeals court.

Now the United States Supreme Court will decide if Whitfield forcibly moved Parnell after the bank robbery. That's the legal definition of the crime that earned him the life sentence.

"The Supreme Court case has kind of brought it all back to us," David Hains, Parnell's son-in-law, said. "Our family is shocked and saddened that this case is going on."

Larry Whitfield is scheduled to be released in May 2032, but depending how the Supreme Court rules, he could win his freedom earlier.

"Our family got to know Mr. Winfield through what he said to police officers," said Hains. "This is a very, very dangerous person. He represents a danger to our society and he should be in prison for as long as we can possibly keep him there."

Whitfield's attorney Joshua Carpenter of Asheville based Federal Defenders of Western Carolina wouldn't comment on the pending case. But Charlotte Attorney Matthew Fleishman says the Supreme Court probably wants to set a definition of what forcible accompaniment means.

"The question of course is, if I am robbing the bank and I grab you from one end of the bank to the other, is that enough to satisfy it," Fleishman said. "Or, do I have to have you at gunpoint and take you as a hostage outside? These are the questions and different courts have come to different decisions when interpreting it."

Whatever decision the Supreme Court makes, the Parnell family says the outcome will remain the same.

"He barged into her home after robbing a bank and he scared her to death," Hains said. "My mother-in-law would not have died had Mr. Whitfield not barged into her home and led her or whatever into another room."

For the Parnell family this is not an exercise in legal hair-splitting. It's a clear case of cause and effect.


Powered by WorldNow

WJZY FOX 46
3501 Performance Rd.
Charlotte, NC 28214
Main Number: (704) 398-0046

Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices